Written materials used in teaching may be of limited use with pre-literate,
non-literate, and semi-literate learners, and their retention of class material
may be limited because they
cannot use educational texts or take notes for later review. Because of their
limited educational experiences, they may feel intimidated about learning English.
At the same
time, they are often highly motivated to learn. They need opportunities to increase
their self-confidence in educational situations and to develop positive images
of themselves as
readers and writers (Goldberg, 1997; Strucker, 1997). They also may have learning
disabilities that have not been diagnosed or addressed (Schwarz & Terrill, 2000).
Programs should have procedures to identify and meet the needs of English language
learners with
learning disabilities. (See Artiles & Ortiz, 2002; Schwarz & Terrill, 2000,
and Adult English Language Learners and Learning Disabilities for discussions of ways
to identify and work with these learners.)
The following groups of learners are literate in their first language, have already developed
reading skills, have formed reading behaviors, and know that written language can represent
speech. Described below are characteristics and implications for teaching reading to
individuals from these groups.
- Learners who are literate in a language with a non-alphabetic script (e.g.,
Chinese or Japanese) may focus on entire words rather than on letters or other
word parts (as
English readers do when using phonological decoding to identify words). This
is because the symbols in non-alphabetic scripts often represent syllables
or entire
words. The written symbols in these languages do not represent sounds, as letters
do in alphabetic languages. Therefore, like young readers, as described in
the report of
the National Reading Panel (2000), they must develop an
"alphabetic strategy"
(Birch, 2002, p. 33) to be able to read and write in an alphabetic script (Adams,
1990).
- Learners who are literate in a language with a non-Roman alphabetic script (e.g.,
Arabic, Greek, Korean, Russian, or Thai) know how to read with an alphabet, but
they may struggle to find English words in the dictionary, and they need time to
process written materials presented in class, because the writing system of their first
language is different from that of English, both in the letters and, in some cases the
directionality of the writing (e.g., Arabic, which is written from right to left).
- Learners who are literate in a language with a Roman-alphabetic script (e.g.,
French, German, or Spanish) know about sound/symbol correspondences. With
regard to vocabulary, they may find many linguistic similarities between their native
languages and English. They can study ESL texts and take notes in class to learn
new vocabulary or structures, and they can read outside of class. They still need to
learn the sound-symbol correspondences of English before they are able to read well
(Hilferty, 1996; Strucker & Davidson, 2003).
|